Showing posts with label smart phone technology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label smart phone technology. Show all posts

Friday, June 24, 2011

Tesco's Homeplus Chain in South Korea Scores Home Run With Smart Phone-Enabled Virtual Grocery Stores in Subway Stations


Food & Grocery Retailing 2.0

As part of its search for different ways and formats to reach food and grocery shoppers in South Korea, where its Homeplus is the second-largest retail chain after number one E-mart, United Kingdom-based Tesco recently created virtual stores in subway stations (pictured at top) in the city of Seoul as a way to try to make grocery shopping more convenient for the busy and time-pressed urban residents in what has become one of the most work-focused country's in the world.

The Homeplus discount chain is jointly-owned by Tesco and Samsung, with Tesco holding 94% of the stock in the venture.

The 115-store chain consists of big discount hypermarkets - which are similar to a Walmart supercenter in merchandise selection and similar to a mini mall in that the big marts also feature numerous independently operated (they lease from Tesco) smaller stores like travel agencies fast-food shops, bookstores and others inside them- along with smaller Express format stores. Homeplus also has an e-commerce store or mall.

Tesco's strategy with Homeplus in its quest to overtake E-mart, which is owned by Shinsegae Group, as South Korea's leading retailer is to find different ways, in addition to building actual stores, to use the online world to grow its sales.

It's Homeplus online store or mall is now the number one e-commerce site for groceries, general merchandise and consumer goods in the nation, which offers it a solid base in those strategic efforts. The virtual stores located in the subway stations are an extension of that online paradigm and strategy.

The Homeplus product-less stores in the subway stations consist of virtual grocery shelves and fresh and perishable food cases, which are designed to look just like the inside of a brick-and-mortar store, as you can see in the photograph at top.

Shoppers walk up to the virtual store, choose the items they want to buy, and then scan the product QR code using their smart phone.

Once the product QR code is scanned, the item goes into a shopper's online grocery cart.

When a shopper completes his or her purchases, they then request a time for the groceries to be delivered to their home later in the day.

The concept is essentially three-fold for Tesco's Homeplus.

First, research conducted for Tesco by the Seoul, South Korea office of marketing firm Cheil Worldwide showed that a significant percentage of urban-living and hard-working South Koreans are finding the task of weekly grocery shopping to be a burden because they're so busy at work,with family and in other activities.

Additionally, many South Korean consumers expressed a preference for being able to use waiting time, such as waiting for their subway car in the station, in productive ways.

Therefore putting these two consumer insights together resulted in the concept of attempting to allow people to shop at Homeplus wherever they may be, so to speak.

The rapid adoption and use of smart phones in South Korea also made possible the concept of converting this waiting time to shopping time, since all the technology needed to access and order groceries from the virtual subway station-based stores is contained in the hands of most urban consumers who use the subway system.


From November 2010 through January of this year, Cheil Worldwide (which produced the three minute video above featuring a look at the subway stores) launched a marketing and advertising campaign for the Homeplus virtual subway station stores. During the three month period, 10,287 consumers visited the Homeplus online store using smart phones, according to the firm. Additionally, the number of new registered members rose by 76%, and on-line sales increased 130%.

Before taking over as the head of United Kingdom-headquartered Tesco in March of this year, CEO Philip Clarke was in charge of the global retailer's operations in South Korea in his position as head of Tesco's European and Asian operations, its second largest unit after the United Kingdom.

Yesterday, Cheil Worldwide's office in Seoul, South Korea, which created the virtual subway stores for Tesco's Homeplus, won three awards for its marketing, adverting and communications campaign for the concept and brand at the 56th annual Cannes International Festival of Creativity (in France), which is affiliated with the famous film festival of the same name - Cannes.

The firm won a Grand Prix (the festival's highest award) in Media, and two Gold Lions in the direct advertising and Outdoor advertising categories, for the virtual subway stores. (See here.)

Tesco's Homeplus says it's looking for other similar venues in South Korea where it might put the virtual stores. Among the key criteria for such locations are public places and spaces that attract a high volume of people on a regular basis, along with having the "captured audience" characteristics of the subway stations, meaning places where people congregate and even better have to wait for something or someone.

The Homeplus virtual subway station-based stores from Tesco is one of the more innovative food and grocery retailing concepts we've seen over the last couple years.

It's also, in our analysis, a perfect example of where smart phone technology is taking us when it comes to retailing. In the not too distant future, don't be surprised if instead of using the conventional checkout stand in the supermarket or other format retail store (it's already starting in limited tests), shoppers instead will use their smart phones to ring up their own purchases, along with using the devices to pay for the purchases, in what is going to be the next wave of global retailing evolution.

The virtual stores, in subways or other public space are, in our analysis, a niche business with limited widespread utility for Tesco or any other retailer at present and in the near-to-medium term. But that's fine because that's as it's intended to be - one of a number of new ways and formats designed to reach shoppers where they are.

It's really all about convenience - bringing the store to the consumer - although it's important to note South Koreans' can already access the Homeplus online store with their smart phones wherever they are.

But the subway station-based virtual store does have the added benefit of the visual - the big screens depicting the virtual grocery shelves in the photograph at top.

It also has what we call the "captured audience element," meaning the subway stations, where the chief human activity is waiting, offer a good venue for suggestive selling (or shopping), which is really the key marketing feature behind the offering. A place featuring a captured audience throughout the day and night, with time on its hands while it waits, equals a good potential venue to get people to interact with the virtual grocery store and do some shopping.

We're going to be seeing numerous new and innovative experiments like the virtual stores from Tesco, Walmart and other retailers over the next few years, all made possible because of the smart phone and the new technology being added to it on what seems like a daily basis.

Stay tuned.

Monday, March 22, 2010

Fresh & Easy Looking Into Accepting Mobile, Digital Manufacturers' Cents-Off Coupons; But the Jury is Still Out


Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market is looking at potentially adopting a program which would allow its stores to accept digital, paperless manufacturer's cents-off coupons, using either its own mobile phone-enabled application, or more likely by partnering with one of the existing mobile, digital couponing companies, such as Cellfire, Shortcuts or another, Fresh & Easy Buzz has learned.

As we've written about extensively, Fresh & Easy doesn't accept manufacturers' coupons - either the traditional paper or the newer mobile, digital versions - at its 147 fresh food and grocery stores in California, Nevada and Arizona.

Instead, Fresh & Easy regularly distributes its own store coupons - both via its Web site and in direct-mail flyers - in versions like $5-off purchases of $20, $6-off $30 or more and $10-off $50 or more. The store coupons are paper, either already in that form, or downloaded from the web by consumers and then printed out.

The key differences between manufacturers' cents-off coupons and store coupons like those Fresh & Easy uses are: (1) the manufacturers' coupons are for (discounts on) single items or products, while the Fresh & Easy coupons are a certain dollar amount "off" of total purchases; and (2) grocers get reimbursed by the manufacturers' for the face value of the coupons they issue that are redeemed by the retailers (plus a small handling charge), while the discount on the Fresh & Easy store coupons comes out of the grocery chain's own profit margins.

Based on the information we have, Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market has not yet decided to go forward with a mobile, digital couponing program, but is looking into the possibility of doing so for its stores.

The easiest way for Fresh & Easy to get into the mobile, digital couponing game, something many of its competitors such as Kroger Co. and Safeway Stores, Inc. already are doing, would be to partner with a third-party company like Cellfire or one of the others.

Such companies already have the technology available to enable grocers like Fresh & Easy to adopt a program without much upfront development cost.

These companies also have relationships with the packaged goods manufacturers and marketers that issue the coupons. The total system is in place in a package for retailers.

For example, Kroger Co. which operates the Ralphs and Food-4-Less chains in Southern California; Fry's in Arizona; and Smith's Food & Drug in Nevada, partners with Cellfire for its mobile couponing system. Cellfire's system offers both traditional coupons that can be obtained via the internet and then printed out, and digital coupons available on cell and smart phones.

And Safeway operates the Vons chain in Southern California, Central California and Southern Nevada; and under its Safeway banner in Arizona.

A major key to a mobile, digital couponing system like Cellfire is that a retailer has a loyalty card program, something Kroger Co. does have but Tesco's Fresh & Easy doesn't at present. However, some third-party mobile, digital couponing systems will work for a retailer even if it doesn't have a loyalty card program.

The way this works is that a shopper merely shows the checkout clerk the various digital coupons he or she has on their mobile phone during the checkout process. The clerk then deducts the digital coupon discounts from the customer's order on the store's POS system, just as they do with a paper coupon.

This presents a problem however for Fresh & Easy, since it's stores have self-service checkout only. As such, store clerks would have to assist shoppers whenever they have digital coupons on their mobile phones to be deducted from their respective grocery purchase orders. This could be so frequent it might turn self-service checkout into full-service, which is something Fresh & Easy's senior management doesn't want to do.

Therefore, since Fresh & Easy doesn't currently have a loyalty card program, it would have to use this second alternative (the human checkout clerk) in order to be able to use the existing third-party mobile, digital couponing systems, based on the current technology available.

Barring bringing on a loyalty card program, or having store clerks assist each customer who has mobile coupons on their mobile device to be deducted, Tesco's Fresh & Easy either would have to create its own mobile, digital coupon application, or in partnership with an existing third-party mobile couponing company, figure out a way to get around these two limiting factors.

Fresh & Easy's CEO, Tim Mason, was in the past the IT marketing manager for Tesco in the United Kingdom. It was under Mason in 1996 that Tesco launched its first online grocery Web site, which was developed by Nick Lansley, a programmer and analyst in the company's IT department at the time.

Today, Lansley is Tesco's resident IT guru. He would be the go-to-guy we would look at to solve the mobile, digital couponing dilemma for Fresh & Easy described above.

One of Lansley's major focuses for Tesco in the United Kingdom currently is developing various smart phone applications involving Tesco's Clubcard loyalty card program, for example.

One of the key reasons Fresh & Easy is looking into a mobile, digital couponing program is because its received numerous complaints about not accepting paper manufacturers' cents off coupons over the last two-plus years its been in business.

Additionally, since the grocer started actively asking its followers on Twitter and Facebook for feedback, suggestions and ideas starting in about mid-2009 - which Fresh & Easy responds to well on the social media sites -one of those frequent suggestions from shoppers has been that it accept manufacturers' cents off coupons. And as more and more grocers adopt mobile, digital coupons in Fresh & Easy's market regions, more shoppers have also been suggesting that it to accept the paperless coupons.

Tesco's Fresh & Easy doesn't want to accept paper of any kind. In addition to not taking paper manufacturers' coupons, the stores accept no paper personal or payroll checks or WIC Vouchers, the check-like government vouchers given to poor mothers. They do accept their own paper Fresh & Easy store coupons however.

The grocer believes the labor savings from not accepting paper checks, WIC Vouchers or manufacturers' coupons in its stores outweighs the benefits of taking them, even though virtually all of its major competitors do take all of the above.

A mobile couponing system that accepts digital manufacturers' coupons would, if it can be technologically adopted given Fresh & Easy's limitations as we described above, allow the grocer to at least capture some of the business from coupon shoppers it's not getting in its stores that it's giving away to competitors, virtually all of which welcome and accept paper manufacturers' cents-off coupons and increasingly are adopting their own mobile, digital couponing systems. And, there's a substantial amount of business from frequent coupon clipper-users out there.

We've said in numerous pieces in Fresh & Easy Buzz over the last two-plus years that Tesco's Fresh & Easy is making a huge mistake by not accepting manufacturers' cents-off coupons of all types - traditional paper, paper coupons clipped out by consumers via internet sites, and mobile, digital coupons.

It's been, and remains, our analysis that Tesco's Fresh & Easy is missing the boat by not accepting all forms of these manufacturer-issued coupons in its stores, particularly in light of the fact that consumer use of the coupons, including traditional paper ones, has soared over the last two years, and is expected to increase again in 2010.

We believe one sign that Fresh & Easy has decided not to go forward with a mobile system that would allow it to take digital manufacturers' coupons is if the grocer comes out with a digital version of its current paper store coupons, which are distributed regularly via the web, and in paper format by direct mail, and sometimes in the stores.

It's our analysis that if Fresh & Easy does this anytime soon, it will mean, at least for the foreseeable future, it has no plans for a mobile couponing program which would allow the grocery chain to accept digital versions of manufacturers' cents-off coupons in its stores.

[Readers: Click here and here (plus, see the links there) to read a selection of past posts from Fresh & Easy Buzz about the manufacturers' coupon phenomenon, mobile coupons, digital coupons and related issues and topics.]